PDA

View Full Version : How is my Varlamov and Neuvirth for their Giroux?



flyt300
02-10-2011, 11:43 AM
The other manager's roster below. Plenty to drop in a 2 for 1.
Is this fair or am I giving too much or too little? I would like help in A or PPG, PPA.

Forwards/Defensemen
C - Jason Spezza (Ott - C)
C - Matt Duchene (Col - C)
C - Travis Zajac (NJ - C)
LW - Andrei Kostitsyn (Mon - LW)
LW - Andrew Ladd (Atl - LW)
LW - David Booth (Fla - LW)
RW - Jamie Langenbrunner (Dal - RW)
RW - Radim Vrbata (Pho - RW)
RW - Jakub Voracek (Cls - RW)
D - Stephane Robidas (Dal - D)
D - Sergei Gonchar (Ott - D)
D - Jack Johnson (LA - D)
Util - Claude Giroux (Phi - RW)
BN - Patrick Marleau (SJ - C,LW)
BN - Dan Boyle (SJ - D)
BN - Niclas Bergfors (Atl - RW)
BN - Zach Bogosian (Atl - D)
BN - Erik Johnson (StL - D)
Goaltenders
G - Tomas Vokoun (Fla - G)
G - Craig Anderson (Col - G)

Raja
02-10-2011, 12:27 PM
Not bad, but I don't think he'll accept since he already has 2 starting goalies. You'd need to add a forward piece and take Anderson back in return I'd imagine. Considering you're taking one of his keepers and not giving one back it's not exactly a fair move.

looch17
02-10-2011, 01:03 PM
Not bad, but I don't think he'll accept since he already has 2 starting goalies. You'd need to add a forward piece and take Anderson back in return I'd imagine. Considering you're taking one of his keepers and not giving one back it's not exactly a fair move.Agreed. Don't see him doing unless you are taking a goalie in return. Could be wrong though always worth a try I suppose.

gogoayane
02-10-2011, 01:18 PM
His wingers are actually quite weak for a 10-teamer... Giroux is probably the best winger he got (I counted Marleau as a C).

I think this is a fair trade and he might actually accept it seeing Anderson has been playing pretty bad lately. This trade helps him solidify his G.

Raja
02-10-2011, 01:38 PM
His wingers are actually quite weak for a 10-teamer... Giroux is probably the best winger he got (I counted Marleau as a C).

I think this is a fair trade and he might actually accept it seeing Anderson has been playing pretty bad lately. This trade helps him solidify his G.

With this logic, why would he give up his best winger for 2 goalies? Anderson has sucked but his offense will be terrible without him.

flyt300
02-11-2011, 12:24 AM
Not bad, but I don't think he'll accept since he already has 2 starting goalies. You'd need to add a forward piece and take Anderson back in return I'd imagine. Considering you're taking one of his keepers and not giving one back it's not exactly a fair move.

Doh... I was thinking they would drop Anderson.

keyboard
02-11-2011, 01:08 AM
What an awful team.

You should ask for Anderson in the trade, make it more clear your intentions.

As stated above, you're asking for one of his top three best players (granted that isn't saying much) so I wonder if he'd even bother.